Baseball
- 1992 - Steve Strack
- 2010 - Matt Whidden
- 2012 - Calvin Sluberski
- 2014 - Chris Beer
- 2016 - Matt Matre, Michael Colosi
- 2017 - Christian Young, David Lyskawa
- 2018 - Vincent Chiarenza, Matt Cross, Joe Kruszka
- 2019 - Erik Johnson, Vincent Chiarenza
- 2021 - Ryan Peterson, Scottie O'Bryan
- 2022 - Kyle Finn
- 2023 - Ryan Birchard, Alex Minnehan, Nicholas Castellana
- 2024 - Andrew Stillinger, Andrew Johnson, Gavyn Boyle
Men's Golf
- 2017 - Shane Helbig
- 2021 - Sam Hyman
- 2022 - Leo Camilloni, Sean Barrett, Zac Golibersuch
- 2023 - Sean Barrett, Leo Camilloni
- 2024 - Adam Firkins
Women's Golf
- 2022 - McCarthy Lang, Kennedy Lang
- 2023 - McCarthy Lang
Men's Basketball
- 1966 - Alan Shug
- 1974 - Pat Lewis
- 1979 - Berry Right
- 2015 - Sheldon Zablotny-Crosby
- 2017 - Jamal Pollydore
- 2018 - Donel Cathcart
- 2021 - Kailee White
- 2022 - Justin Hendrick
- 2023 - Lamar Lovelace
Men's Bowling
- 1977 - Richard Ackerson
- 1979 - Bart Rojek
- 1981 - Bill Coder, Jim Reese, Bob Meidenbauer
- 1982 - Jim Reese, Sean Perry, Bob Meidenbauer
- 1983 - Sean Perry
- 1984 - Ken Pelletier
- 1987 - James Greedy
- 1996 - John Sparace
- 1997 - Tom Brady
- 2013 - Jake Hayes
Men's Cross Country
- 1967 - Chris Thomas
Men's Swimming & Diving
- 1984 - James E. Daly
Women's Basketball
- 1998 - Michelle Milleville
- 2014 - Jaclyn Welch
- 2017 - Taliyah Hopkins
- 2019 - Kenetria Redfern
- 2020 - Paige Emborsky
- 2021 - Alaina Forbes
- 2022 - Alaina Forbes
- 2023 - Aichata Ballo
- 2024 - Faith Alessandra
Women's Bowling
- 1980 - Laurrie Marvin
- 1981 - Laura Harmon
- 1982 - Shelly Ann Bulgreen
- 1983 - Kim Alvord
- 1986 - Pat Rankin
- 1992 - Debbie Jordan
Women's Cross Country
- 1982 - Becky Heuer
Women's Soccer
- 2005 - Laura Freeman
Softball
- 2023 - Maggiemay Murrins
Women's Swimming & Diving
- 1984 - Donna Killian
Women's Volleyball
- 2011 - Jessica Crooks
- 2012 - Kristine Ripson
- 2013 - Delaney Laper
Wrestling
- 1975 - Bob Sanders
- 1977 - Willie Moore
- 1978 - Al Grimes
- 1982 - Mike Morley
- 1986 - Kevin Bos
- 1988 - Wes Askew
- 1989 - Mark Jurek
- 1991 - Dan Uhteg
- 1993 - Troy Thomas
- 1994 - Brian Dowdall, Mark Bowman, Willie Cunningham, Jon Hoover, Paul Conibear
- 1995 - Mike Rogers, Tim Fike
- 1999 - Brad Rowe, Jeff Mye, Rashad Evans
- 2000 - Rashad Evans, Mahnseah Boley
- 2001 - Tevon Fordyce
- 2003 - Derek Ostrowski
- 2004 - Bill Morello
- 2005 - Josh Lange, Kyle Schmelzle
- 2006 - Colin Thompson
- 2007 - Dale DeBacco
- 2008 - Justin James, Patrick Hagerty, Dale DeBacco
- 2009 - Shay Shive, John Taylor, Jared Lemke
- 2010 - Shay Shive
- 2011 - Kyle Gibas, Troy Ireland
- 2012 - Kris Schimek, Lance Moore
- 2013 - Kris Schimek, Irvin Buck
- 2016 - Zach Colgan, Anthony Liberatore, Cody McGregor, Alex Kelly
- 2017 - Troy Keller
- 2018 - Troy Keller, John Reina
- 2019 - Greg Quinn, Freddy Eckles
- 2020 - Jordan Bushey, Frankie Gissendaner, Mason Gray
- 2022 - Frankie Gissendaner
- 2024 - Kace Cook